Monday, December 2, 2013

Romance Writers, Look... Just... Please... Don't.

Okay, I'm going to start with the disclaimer that I've recently cut my hair short and all of these cowlicks I didn't have two weeks ago are now making me look like a rejected Muppet. So it's possible I'm just having a bad hair day and I'm cranky.
That being said, I wanted to mention some things that I've noticed a few Romance Writers doing that are driving me, and a few other editors from whom I gathered a consensus, up the metaphorical editorial wall. We've come up with a couple of topics:

1. Quit with the hair tucked behind the ear thing already. It's a tender gesture, and many heroines have unruly gorgeous hair (without f-ing cowlicks, I bet). But probably more than 30 of the 40 romance stories I've worked on this year have had a moment where the hero tucks that stray strand or lock of the heroine's hair behind her ear. To this I must say: There are other gestures you could use! How about that little brush of the backs of his fingers against hers, or the gentle nudge of a knuckle to her chin, or the way he tips his knee forward to tap hers? How about he leans in and just whispers by her cheek? I had a boyfriend who used to tuck my hair behind my ear (he also liked me to tilt my ankles a certain way and he later became a shoe salesman, but that's a different story...) and it drove me crazy. So maybe this one's just me, but then again, maybe not...

2. Location, Location, Location, or Sex on a Horse. Second disclaimer: I have honestly only read of people having sex on top of moving horses three times, and of people having sex on a camel once. Personally, however, I think that many times is really too many. If you ride horses, you know that there's a certain rhythm to the different gaits, and two people in the midst of lovemaking will have to really concentrate to match that, not to mention staying balanced and holding on to the horse, since it's a long way down. Having never tried to "go equestrian" myself, I could be wrong, but I do have a friend who damaged her lover just by being overly vigorous on a downward move, and they were on a completely non-moving bed. If nothing else, think of the poor embarrassed horse, having to face his horse friends' snickers the next day. How would you feel if two horses were entangling themselves on your back? 
The point is that if you are going to put lovers in unusual situations, please think about the logistics. I read a story where the desperate lovers were robbing a bank and got carried away back in the vault. I couldn't focus on the romance because I was worried they'd be locked in there by the quick-thinking bank manager and suffocate. One love scene placed the couple on a boat in the windy Puget Sound in early Spring -- I kept thinking "Not on the deck! Not on the deck! Go into the cabin, for heaven's sake, before you freeze off your important bits!" I read one fantasy where the lovers were riding off on a unicorn-like creature. Fine, I thought, maybe he floats. That could work. 
Let's not even discuss camels. 

3.  Just stop talking and do it. Communication is good. Especially between two people who are intimate with each other. Sometimes dialogue can make a love scene, or even just a quiet private moment, explicitly hot or passionate. Good stuff. But speaking during intimate encounters should not derail the tension and intensity a good love scene should have. If your characters are lovers in a romantic suspense, for instance, and they're in the midst of that driving force that takes their breath, neither of them should be thinking, or talking, about the terrorist or murderer they're trying to thwart: "pant, pant --'I really hope we catch Marko the Devilish tomorrow' -- moan, pant..." . If your heroine is a hometown girl working things out with that long lost sweetheart and everything depends on the success of the fund-raising picnic the next day, don't have her express her distracted thoughts, in the middle of their doing something spectacularly hot, of having enough sandwiches on hand in case his grandmother brings her knitting friends along. Even if Gran's sweet as pie and the reason they've been thrown together in the first place -- here's the Golden Rule: No Granny in the Bedroom. Ew. 

4. You said that already. I know this one's hard to avoid, especially since it's virtually impossible to write an entire novel at a single sitting, and also to remember every word you put into your story. But many writers have a tendency to re-state the back story, or elements of their characters' descriptions, again and again. Please remember to re-read your work, from beginning to end, after you've let it sit for a week or two, or have someone you trust read it, so they can tell you if you've written phrases like "He was doing it all for the men in uniform, who deserved the best he had" or paragraphs that start "She had always wanted to help the children of the town by ..." over and over, or even if you've just repeatedly described a character as having "piercing/intense/sparkling (choose your adjective) blue/green/hazel eyes." 

5.  You could have finished this thirty pages ago! She loves him but there's a Big Misunderstanding. He loves her but there's another Big Misunderstanding. She apologizes, and even though he loves her he can't forgive. Then he apologizes but even though she loves him she can't forgive. Both of them spend pages regretting how things turned out. They want each other like nothing else, but then they avoid each other like the plague. There are at least three black moments.
Look. People have conflicts. Resolutions make for stronger relationships. The bigger the comeback from the deeper the black moment, the happier the ending. But don't make your characters bounce too much-- don't make them so intractable or clueless that their actions become implausible, or worse, so repetitive they become frustrating to the reader. You never want a reader to think, "Jeez God, Jake's/Amanda's/Luke's/Chloe's so stupid! How many times can they go back and forth? Why don't they just talk about this?!" Try seeing the highs and lows of your story, keeping in mind whether the peaks and valleys in the relationship help the story progress or just put your hero and heroine through a tangled up obstacle course.

And finally:
6. Stop naming your heroes Luke and Jake. What. You think I'm kidding? You try reading 40 romance novels a year and you'll see what I mean.

Do you have any pet peeves that you've noticed when reading certain types of stories? Are there any plot points or too-often-used character traits that make you cringe or groan? 


11 comments:

  1. I'm now going back through my current WIP to take out any hair tucks. *slinks away*

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No slinking! And you don't have to take them ALL out... how many could you possibly have? :)
      Thanks for commenting, Jeannie.

      Delete
  2. Excellent! Love this! It is the world of cliches in every shape and form. Hair tucking, eyeballs wandering rooms looking for the beloved, searching souls or maybe it should be soles. And yes, the names. Always Luke and Jake who are always so manly and sure of themselves. The heroine moves back to the small town and falls for Luke Delmonte who is a fireman/farmer/rancher/forklift operator with a dark and mysterious past.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Y'know, I have never heard of a fork lift operator ... I might have to use that. What kind of dark and mysterious past do you think he might have?
      Thanks for stopping in, Robin.

      Delete
  3. I think you're on this hair tuck thing because you've chopped all yours off - well, not all of it... damn it to hell, though, I'm going to go back over some of my WIPS with your advice in mind!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    2. Ha! I think it's worse when the heroine is described as having perky, sassy short hair and there's still hair tucking. What is he tucking? Long eyebrows?
      It took a while to organize and write this one, even before I cut my long braid off. So there, Smartypants :) !
      Thanks for stopping by!

      Delete
  4. I laughed throughout your entire post, Lynne. I agree that it's critical we writers focus on using gestures that are unique to our character and not cliché. I also agree with the importance of rereading our work thoroughly and cut out those annoying repetitions. I can't even comment on the horse tirade. Too funny for words. But the best part was when I read the two most popular hero names. My first book's hero was Jacob. LOL That ms is yet to be published, but when I revise it, I will be certain to change his name. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I was wondering if anyone was going to mention the horse thing... I'm sorry I picked on your hero's name! Maybe there should be a blog on the LEAST common names, and we'll start some new trends.
      Thanks for your comments, Jolyse.

      Delete
  5. Great points, Lynne and funny!
    Yeah I can just imagine the "talk" back at the stable between the horses after the trick riders return from their exploits.

    I hate when there's too much info or detail. I'm usually saying yadda, yadda. What's the point here? Another one is when things don't make logical sense and the author tries to pass it off as it does. AND another favorite grip is usually in chick lit stories where the heroine gets mad at the hero for not seeing things her way and won't see or talk to him and the author assumes all females think like that. In those cases I'm think the heroine is stupid and I'm wondering what the hell the hero sees in this idiot.

    Great posts. Love reading them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I see that sort of thing a lot, too. It's unfortunate that sometimes authors get so wrapped up in one aspect or character of their story that they don't always take the time to flesh out all sides of a situation, or create depth in as many of the characters as possible.
      Too funny about the horses, Donna. Now you have me thinking about an essay from the horses' point of view. I probably should not have too much wine later...

      Thanks for commenting!

      Delete